Current:Home > FinanceJustice Department reverses position, won't support shielding Trump in original E. Jean Carroll lawsuit-LoTradeCoin
Justice Department reverses position, won't support shielding Trump in original E. Jean Carroll lawsuit
View Date:2024-12-23 15:30:25
The Justice Department on Tuesday reversed its position that former President Donald Trump was shielded from a 2019 defamation lawsuit filed by the writer E. Jean Carroll.
The government had originally argued that Trump was protected from liability by the Westfall Act, because he was acting as a federal employee. Under the act, federal employees are entitled to absolute immunity from personal lawsuits for conduct occurring within the scope of their employment.
Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Brian Boynton wrote in a letter Tuesday to attorneys for Trump and Carroll that a jury's determination in a separate civil lawsuit that Trump was liable for sexual abuse and defamation of Carroll factored into the decision. That lawsuit was filed in November 2022 and involved statements Trump made after his presidency.
"The allegations that prompted the statements related to a purely personal incident: an alleged sexual assault that occurred decades prior to Mr. Trump's Presidency," Boynton wrote. "That sexual assault was obviously not job-related."
Carroll filed her first lawsuit in 2019, while Trump was still president — and after he accused her of "totally lying" when she said he sexually assaulted her in a high-end New York City department store in the 1990s. In October 2021, a federal judge in New York ruled that Trump was not shielded from Carroll's suit. In 2022, the 2nd Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals reversed the lower court's decision and suggested the Westfall Act could protect Trump from liability in the case.
The lawsuit has remained active and has yet to go to trial. After the jury found Trump liable in April, Carroll amended the suit, adding new defamation claims related to more recent statements made by Trump, and he filed a countersuit.
The Justice Department had initially argued that even though "the former president made crude and offensive comments in response to the very serious accusations of sexual assault" the law protecting employees like the president from such a lawsuit should be upheld.
But the Justice Department reviewed that decision after the jury in Carroll's second lawsuit in New York found Trump liable for sexual abuse and defamation, Boynton wrote. It concluded that Trump had not acted "out of a desire to serve the government" when he denied her claims.
Boynton also cited statements Trump has made about Carroll in the years since his presidency ended.
"These post-Presidency statements, which were not before the Department during the original scope certification in this case, tend to undermine the claim that the former President made very similar statements at issue in Carroll out of a desire to serve the government," Boynton wrote.
Carroll's attorney, Roberta Kaplan expressed gratitude for the department's reversal and said in a statement, "We have always believed that Donald Trump made his defamatory statements about our client in June 2019 out of personal animus, ill will, and spite, and not as President of the United States."
She added that "we look forward to trial in E Jean Carroll's original case in January 2024."
An attorney for Trump did not immediately return a request for comment.
- In:
- E. Jean Carroll
- Lawsuit
- Donald Trump
- New York
Graham Kates is an investigative reporter covering criminal justice, privacy issues and information security for CBS News Digital. Contact Graham at [email protected] or [email protected]
veryGood! (6973)
Related
- King Charles III celebrates 76th birthday amid cancer battle, opens food hubs
- Below Deck's Captain Jason Shares Update on 2 Fired Crewmembers After Sexual Misconduct Scandal
- Below Deck's Captain Jason Shares Update on 2 Fired Crewmembers After Sexual Misconduct Scandal
- Katy Perry and Orlando Bloom's Daughter Daisy Dove Is in Full Bloom at Her First Public Appearance
- Fire crews on both US coasts battle wildfires, 1 dead; Veterans Day ceremony postponed
- Unpacking the century-long beef over daylight saving time
- When Libs of TikTok tweets, threats increasingly follow
- Online database launched to track missing and murdered Indigenous people
- Alexandra Daddario shares first postpartum photo of baby: 'Women's bodies are amazing'
- Connor Stalions, Michigan football staffer at center of sign-stealing scandal, resigns
Ranking
- Who will be in the top 12? Our College Football Playoff ranking projection
- Ukraine minister says he wants to turn his country into a weapons production hub for the West
- Online database launched to track missing and murdered Indigenous people
- Protest marches by thousands in Europe demand halt to Israeli bombing of Gaza, under police watch
- Only 8 monkeys remain free after more than a week outside a South Carolina compound
- Gunmen kill 5 people in an apparent dispute over fuel theft in central Mexico, police say
- Pentagon pauses support for congressional travel to Israel
- Lisa Vanderpump Makes Rare Comment About Kyle Richards' Separation Amid Years-Long Feud
Recommendation
-
Rita Ora pays tribute to Liam Payne at MTV Europe Music Awards: 'He brought so much joy'
-
Cardinals rookie QB Clayton Tune to start at Browns; Kyler Murray waiting game continues
-
China Premier Li seeks to bolster his country’s economic outlook at the Shanghai export fair
-
Tens of thousands of ancient coins have been found off Sardinia. They may be spoils of a shipwreck
-
Nicole Kidman Reveals the Surprising Reason for Starring in NSFW Movie Babygirl
-
Big Ten commissioner has nothing but bad options as pressure to punish Michigan mounts
-
How a Texas teacher helped students use their imaginations to take flight
-
FDA proposes banning ingredient found in some citrus-flavored sodas